The Lindsay Clancy trial ended this week without a verdict.
After nearly six weeks of testimony and seven days of deliberations, the jury came back 11-1. Eleven jurors agreed. One did not. Mistrial.
I'm not going to get into whether Lindsay Clancy was guilty, insane, mentally ill, criminally responsible, or any of the rest of it. There is no doubt, her actions were evil. Three beautiful little children are dead. The whole thing is horrific, and people obviously disagree about how it should be resolved. The preoccupation and national division resulting from it is extreme to say the least.
What prompts me to write this is larger than the trial itself. The trial is simply, once again, what brought the issue to light. The issue is this: Just maybe our jury system is already irreparably broken and has been for a while.
Americans tend to treat the jury system as almost sacred. The idea that the government shouldn't be able to accuse you of a crime, throw you in prison and throw away the key without first convincing your fellow citizens of your guilt first is a pretty good one. I'm just not convinced the system we've been using for hundreds of years is still the best way to accomplish that considering how dumbed down, divided and siloed we've become as a population.
Remember the O.J. Simpson trial? As a more seasoned citizen, I certainly do.
You could write a book about everything that went wrong in that case. People already have. But it's hard to argue that racial tensions didn't have a huge impact in the outcome of that trial.
After Simpson was acquitted, juror Lionel Cryer raised a clenched fist toward O.J. as the jury left the courtroom. Cryer later said race didn't determine his verdict and that the prosecution simply failed to prove its case. Maybe so.
But a juror giving what certainly appeared to be a Black Power salute toward the defendant immediately after acquitting him probably isn't the best advertisement for an unbiased jury system. I was a police detective at the time. I don't think I'd ever seen so much evidence against one defendant as there was against OJ in that case.
Then we have the January 6 cases of which I am intimately familiar with. Nearly 1600 defendants were prosecuted in Washington, D.C., me included. I was one of hundreds that went to trial. This is one of the most politically one-sided places in America, for what was essentially a political event that happened right there in their backyard.
Whatever you think about J6, the numbers are remarkable. Not one J6 defendant who went before a jury was completely acquitted. There were a very small number of acquittals on a few individual charges, but not one full jury acquittal.
Shouldn't we at least be willing to look at numbers like this and ask whether venue, politics and the political makeup of the jury pool might matter? Is it unacceptable to ask whether having these types of trials in Washington D.C. was fair to begin with? Were these D.C. juries comprised of our 'peers?'
Now we have Lindsay Clancy. After weeks of complicated testimony involving mental illness, psychosis, medications, and criminal intent, eleven jurors reached one conclusion. One juror wouldn't budge. Some people are furious with that juror. Others think that juror is a hero. Wasn't it that juror's job not to budge if he strongly believed in his position. Yet now he must be concerned about being doxed and his physical safety for sticking to his beliefs.
We take twelve random citizens with completely different educational backgrounds, intelligence levels, life experiences, political beliefs, biases and abilities to understand complicated information and we put them in a courtroom.
Then we throw lawyers at them. Expert witnesses. Psychiatrists. DNA evidence. Cell-phone data. Forensic evidence. Thousands of pages of documents. Complicated rules of evidence.
Then the judge gives them a bunch of legal instructions that half the lawyers in America probably couldn't explain in plain English. The same legal instructions that judges and lawyers go to law school for years to understand the nuances and applications of.
And then the judge tells them: 'OK. Now go sit in that room over there and decide whether this person spends the rest of his or her life in prison.' Or even more ominously, whether the person lives or dies. Maybe there's a better way.
What if being a juror was an actual profession? Imagine professional jurors who had to qualify for the job - a group of diverse, moderate, balanced, intelligent people reflecting their communities and getting paid for their service.
Give them aptitude tests. Test their reasoning ability, reading comprehension and ability to understand complicated information. Do extensive background investigations such as police officers are subjected to.
Then train them extensively. Teach them about evidence and constitutional rights. Educate them on what 'beyond a reasonable doubt' means. Teach them how to evaluate witnesses and expert testimony.
Make it a respected, well-paid profession within our justice system, one that would have many bright and qualified applicants lining up for the jobs. Hold them to extremely high ethical standards. Professional jurors wouldn't work for the prosecution or the defense. Their job would be neutrality, and their loyalty would be to the evidence and the law.
In most states and in most cases, we require judges to go to law school. We require prosecutors and defense attorneys to go to law school. Police officers receive extensive training before they go out into the field, where they then receive even more training. Forensic experts spend years in training. But the people who ultimately decide whether somebody is guilty? We basically pull their names out of a hat. Does that really make sense?
Keep in mind that much of the western world's jury systems already reject the model of a pure 'jury of peers' with no legal training or experience. Many use either a panel of judges, which I would reject based on recent egregious examples of judicial bias and overreach, or a hybrid 'mixed bench' style of jury deliberations. An example of a mixed bench might be a 12-person jury consisting of 3 judges and 9 citizens, each with an equal vote. And yes, the judges could help guide the deliberations and explain the law.
There would be another benefit of a professional juror model. No more jury duty! No more getting the dreaded envelope in the mail and trying to figure out how you're going to miss work, rearrange childcare, cancel a trip or spend three weeks sitting in a courthouse.
There are potential problems with my idea. I realize that. Professional jurors could develop biases of their own. Hear enough criminal cases and suddenly everyone starts looking guilty. Maybe they become too close to prosecutors, judges or the system itself. Those are legitimate concerns.
So, we build safeguards into the system. Term limits. Rotations. Continuing education. Independent oversight. Regular background investigations, an ongoing and regular review of performance., etc.
But when you look at O.J. Simpson, the January 6 trials, the Lindsay Clancy mistrial and countless other controversial cases over the years, I think we should at least be willing to ask whether a system created hundreds of years ago still makes sense exactly as it exists today. What exactly is a 'jury of our peers' anyway?
I don't have all the answers, but I do have an open mind. This discussion is necessary. I think we'd all like to have a little more confidence that the twelve people deliberating in a jury room are actually qualified and capable of determining guilt or innocence. Is that too much to ask?